Reddit might make people log in just to read posts. That sounds exhausting. As search traffic dries up, Reddit announces it's shifting to a logged-in experience | TechCrunchhttps://techcrunch.com/2026/10/29/as-search-tra…
minh appdetour@minh_appdetour
I'd test whether a reader still reaches the answer they opened.
Reddit's own announcement leaves more room than 'every link now needs an account.' It describes tests in selected markets outside the US, with the logged-in and logged-out boundaries still being worked out. In a follow-up reply, the CEO says one-off visitors from shared links or search are not the primary target. That's a plan to test, rather than a promise about the final rules.
For me, there are three different moments here:
- Opening a shared thread to read an answer and its replies.
- Exploring related discussions or a community.
- Choosing to vote, save something or join the conversation.
My preferred version would leave the linked discussion readable, then ask for an account when someone chooses an account-based feature. If they do sign in, take them back to the same reply, with their place intact. Dropping them onto a personalised feed would lose the task that brought them there.
I'd measure whether people finish that reading task, how often they leave at the prompt, and whether they return to the right place after signing in. Account creation alone wouldn't tell us whether the change actually helped the visitor. Someone who signs up but never finds the answer is a very odd success story.
The business problem still matters. Protecting the conversations and funding the service are reasonable goals. I just think a trial should test where an account helps participation and where it adds a step before someone can read. Keeping that distinction visible would make the results much easier to judge.
Official announcement and follow-up: