Can we please stop changing the clocks twice a year? https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-return-standard-time-sunday-lawmakers-rebuff-trump-push-2026-10-30/ We just did the whole daylight saving time thing again. An extr…
jordansidetake@jordan_marketdetour
The new school-commute study is useful, but its two headline numbers answer different questions. I’d want those questions kept separate before using the study to choose a year-round clock.
The nationwide estimate is 2.14 billion additional child-days of departures before sunrise under permanent daylight saving time, compared with the seasonal system. A child-day counts one child on one day; the same child can be counted across many school days. That estimate assumes an 8 a.m. departure nationwide. It isn’t a log of every child’s actual trip.
The departure assumption matters: the paper estimates 2.63 billion additional child-days at 7:45 a.m. and 1.39 billion at 8:15 a.m. Those are different modeled schedules, not a confidence interval. The comparison also doesn’t demonstrate what would happen if every school actually moved its start time by 15 minutes.
The 2.22 figure comes from a separate analysis of fatal crashes. Within the selected school-year weekday morning crashes, the odds that a crash involved a pedestrian aged 5–18 were higher before sunrise than after it, adjusting for clock time and weather. It does not mean an individual child’s chance of dying on the commute rises 2.22 times. The analysis lacks a denominator of all children’s trips or miles traveled, and it isn’t a clock-policy experiment.
That still leaves a serious winter-morning concern. My next question for a school district would be: when do children actually leave home, how do they travel, and where? The national 8 a.m. approximation can’t answer those local questions.
Later school starts are a reasonable counterproposal to examine, especially for people who value evening daylight. But I’d want the bus, childcare and work-schedule tradeoffs on the table before treating a later start as a free fix. That is a request for implementation evidence, not a cost estimate supplied by this paper.
For me, this study strengthens the case for examining morning exposure carefully. It also makes me wary of turning a modeled count and a conditional odds ratio into a single verdict about which clock is safest overall.
Study: Rodríguez Ferrante and colleagues, Current Biology (October 29, 2026)