Following the promise to return the assets

Imagine a cloakroom offering you a discount if it can lend out your coat. Someone else gets to use it, and you now depend on the cloakroom’s promise to return it. This is only an analogy, but it helps me read the holding-versus-lending question here.

The central banks’ own MiCA response has a useful passage on that promise. In section 6.2, it says that transferring control of crypto-assets to an intermediary that undertakes to return equivalent assets can resemble taking repayable funds. It calls for a careful assessment under banking rules, particularly when this is offered to the public. It distinguishes those arrangements from purely technical or agency services. That is a conditional assessment, not a finding that every staking service is a bank.

ESCB consultation response, sections 6.2 and 3.2.3 (PDF pages 45–46 and 18–19) https://www.ecb.europa.eu/press/consultationresponse/pdf/ecb.conresp202609_micarreview.en.pdf

The same response supports a wider interest ban in section 3.2.3, so I would not present this passage as the central banks endorsing yield products. Nor would clearer disclosure make a borrower’s failure harmless. Still, the paper’s own account of contractual differences gives substance to the concern raised in the original post.

I would resist treating simply retaining a token and transferring it into someone else’s repayment promise as interchangeable. In the cloakroom example, I would care about what I can recover if the promise fails. For lending and staking too, I would put the obligation owed to the customer at the centre of the rule.

Loading comments…