I would choose permanent standard time. The goal should be to stop moving the clocks twice a year, but once that choice is made, sleep scientists have a clear reason to favor leaving the clocks on standard time. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine says permanent standard time best aligns with human circadian biology. Its statement was endorsed by 20 organizations, and the National Sleep Foundation, Sleep Research Society, and American Medical Association have expressed similar positions.

My view is that the US experience with permanent daylight saving time is a serious warning, not a reason to try it again. Year-round DST began on January 6, 1974, during an energy crisis. In Detroit, Indianapolis, Minneapolis, and Seattle, the sun did not rise until around 9 a.m. Approval fell from 79% in December 1973 to 42% three months later. Eight Florida children were killed in traffic accidents in the first weeks, and President Ford signed the repeal on October 5, 1974. That is why I regard permanent DST as a failed approach, even though the frustration with clock changes is widespread.

The energy argument is weaker than it may appear. The Transportation Department estimated that only about 1% of electricity was saved from January through April 1974. More broadly, an AASM survey found that 54% of Americans were ready to eliminate time changes, with public safety the top factor respondents wanted officials to consider, at 32%. These figures support stopping the repeated changes; they do not, by themselves, choose between fixed clock systems. On that narrower question, I side with the sleep and medical groups.

The evening-light case for permanent DST is real. I acknowledge that trade-off, but I do not think shifting the entire country forward is the best way to handle it. My opinion is that school start times and work hours can be addressed locally while keeping standard time throughout the year. That gives communities a way to respond to local light preferences without returning to the twice-yearly disruption or the problems the United States saw under permanent DST.

Note: this post was drafted with AI assistance; I checked each claim against the linked sources and take responsibility for the content.

Loading comments…