Hollis Sidebar@hollis_side
Eight Years After the Net Neutrality Repeal, What Can We Actually Measure?
In 2017, the US Federal Communications Commission voted to reverse the net neutrality protections adopted two years earlier.
The changes took effect in 2018, and the debate surrounding them was intense.
Supporters argued that lighter regulation would encourage broadband investment and innovation. Opponents warned that internet providers might favor certain services, create paid fast lanes or limit access to competing content.
Nearly eight years later, we have a better opportunity to compare those predictions with what actually happened.
But the evidence is not as straightforward as either side originally suggested.
1. Network investment is difficult to attribute to one rule
One argument for repeal was that reducing regulatory obligations would encourage internet service providers to invest more in their networks.
That is measurable in principle.
We can examine broadband capital expenditure, fiber deployment, average speeds and network coverage.
The difficulty is separating regulatory effects from other changes.
Demand for faster internet increased during the pandemic. Technology costs changed. Competition varied by location, and state-level rules did not always match federal policy.
If investment rose after repeal, that alone would not prove the repeal caused the increase.
If investment fell, the same caution would apply.
We need a comparison that accounts for the rest of the market.
2. The feared harms were not all equally visible
The public debate often focused on dramatic scenarios: a provider slowing down a rival streaming platform or making customers pay extra to access ordinary websites.
Those are important concerns, but the potential effects of network management can be more subtle.
Differences in traffic treatment, commercial agreements or quality of service may be difficult for an ordinary customer to recognize.
And an absence of widely reported problems does not necessarily establish that the rules made no difference.
It matters whether the monitoring systems were capable of detecting the behavior in the first place.
3. Consumer outcomes matter more than political predictions
The most useful evidence might come from customer-facing outcomes.
Broadband prices, service quality, competition and access are more directly relevant to everyday users than the language of the original regulatory debate.
Even those measures require care.
Prices depend on geography, service bundles and technology. Speed improvements can happen for reasons unrelated to the rules.
A national average may also conceal very different experiences in areas with limited provider choice.
4. A better way to revisit the argument
I don't think the right question is whether everyone who supported or opposed the repeal was right.
The original predictions were too broad for that.
A more useful exercise would take a few specific claims and examine each separately.
Did broadband investment increase relative to a reasonable comparison? Were there documented cases of discriminatory traffic management? Did consumers in less competitive markets experience different outcomes?
Those questions are narrower, but they can produce more meaningful answers.
Eight years is enough time to move beyond slogans.
It isn't enough reason to ignore the difficulties of identifying what actually caused the changes.
Reference: FCC, Restoring Internet Freedom Order; US Government Accountability Office, FCC rule review.