책갈피온도@lukewarmnote
Six years after the remote work shift, how true was the claim that productivity would drop?
There is a common phrase that keeps popping up when reading about remote work.
"Working from home kills productivity."
Conversely, there is this argument:
"It's actually more efficient because you save time on commuting."
Both sound somewhat plausible. But when you look back at the debate that has been ongoing since around 2020, something different stands out.
It's the fact that employee satisfaction with remote work and actual work performance don't always move in the same direction.
An intriguing experiment with 1,612 people
I read a study published in Nature in 2024.
It was an experiment involving 1,612 employees at China's Trip.com that compared a group allowed to work remotely two days a week against a group that worked from the office.
The results were interesting.
The hybrid work group saw a roughly 33% reduction in attrition, and there was no statistically significant negative impact on performance reviews or promotions.
The outcome was a bit different from the simplistic explanation that allowing remote work makes employees happy but comes at a cost to the company.
The original study can be found here.
However, looking at these numbers, I couldn't immediately conclude that every company should adopt remote work.
This is because the experiment focused on employees at a specific company and involved a hybrid model where they worked from home only part of the week, not fully remotely.
Results could be different for jobs that require face-to-face meetings with customers or the use of specific laboratory equipment.
The word 'productivity' has many meanings
Finishing tasks quickly, producing quality results, or ensuring smooth collaboration across the team.
They are all related to productivity, but they aren't the same thing.
Just because an individual has more quiet time to focus doesn't necessarily mean the team's overall decision-making will speed up.
Conversely, meeting in the office often doesn't guarantee that every meeting is efficient.
Another issue is time.
Remote work can be a very different experience for a long-time employee compared to someone who is just starting to learn the ropes.
For someone working alone on familiar tasks, saving commute time is a huge advantage, but for someone who learns by asking questions of the colleague next to them, the office might be more comfortable.
If we don't consider these nuances, sweeping claims that remote work either boosts or harms productivity seem overly broad.
Instead of asking who won,
Six years ago, the main question was whether remote work was even possible.
Now, we can talk more specifically about under what conditions it works well.
How much longitudinal data has been accumulated to compare the effects of remote work on productivity and employee retention across different job types?
I would like to find research that distinguishes between full remote, 2-3 day hybrid, and office-first work.
It would be even better to compare not just work performance, but also new hire training, promotions, turnover rates, and the quality of collaboration.
I'm also curious about what you thought about remote work back in 2020, and whether that perspective has changed after experiencing it for a few years.
It seems it's time to stop calling remote work strictly 'good' or 'bad' and start examining which methods work best for which roles and individuals.
