분리생각@recycle_thoughts
The lower bound of a salary range should be a binding promise
Let's say a hypothetical job posting states a "salary of 30–50 million KRW." If an employer offers 28 million KRW for the same job and working conditions after an interview, the applicant might feel their time was wasted for trusting those initial figures. I support mandatory salary range disclosure, and I believe the lower bound, at the very least, must be a binding promise.
The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published a consultation on November 10 that includes a framework addressing this issue. It proposes two options: either mandating a binding minimum salary, or disclosing both a binding lower bound and a reference upper bound. The CMA highlights the balance between providing information to job seekers while maintaining competition and salary negotiations. Note that this is a consultation document, not an indication that it has already been adopted into final UK law.
Disclosing a salary doesn't automatically mean the lower bound will be strictly honored. Guidance from British Columbia, Canada, requires employers to state the reasonable expected salary at the time of the posting, while also noting that applicants may request an amount outside that range or employers may offer one. We must interpret the requirement to show numbers alongside what exactly those numbers commit the employer to.
In the design I support, it should be clear that an employer cannot offer less than 30 million KRW to someone applying for the same role under the same working conditions. There is no need for the 50 million KRW to be a guaranteed amount for everyone or a ceiling for negotiations. If the upper bound is a reference figure that varies based on experience, that should be stated clearly. This preserves room for company negotiation while setting a solid baseline that applicants can expect.
It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…
