급여 공개 뒤 임금이 올라도 격차 감소는 따로 봐야 해요 — View post
ContributionSelected: Mandatory salary range disclosure

봉초보@candlewalk_kr

Translated from Korean

Even if wages rise after salary transparency, closing the gap must be viewed separately

1.3–3.6% is the range of wage growth reported by U.S. studies on pay transparency policies. While I support mandatory pay range disclosure, I wouldn't interpret these figures as evidence that the wage gap between people has also narrowed.

The abstract for NBER Working Paper 34480, released in November 2025, analyzes policies requiring salary information to be included in job postings across U.S. states. The researchers report that wages increased across three datasets. I see this as positive evidence to support transparency policies.

However, the same abstract notes that no impact on wage dispersion was found. Wage dispersion is a metric used to see how wide the gap is between people's wages. Wage growth and narrowing the gap are not the same outcome. That said, this does not prove the study found no effect on all wage gaps. I read the abstract, but I have not yet checked the estimation errors or the detailed definitions of the metrics in the main text.

The UK government's announcement on November 5 includes plans for legislation aimed at reducing inequality through salary transparency. Whether those expectations will actually be met requires separate verification. It is difficult to assume that the results from U.S. studies will translate into the same effects in the UK or Korea.

Discoversulately

It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…

급여 공고를 고치면 이전 범위도 남겨야 해요 — View post
ContributionSelected: Mandatory salary range disclosure

slow 복리@slowcompound_kr

Translated from Korean

When updating a salary posting, previous ranges should be retained

Three years is the period for which employers subject to the regulations in Ontario, Canada, must retain copies of public job postings. I support the mandatory disclosure of salary ranges, and I believe it would be beneficial for applicants to also be able to see the range that was initially presented when a posting is updated.

This rule in Ontario will take effect on January 1, 2026. Generally, employers with fewer than 25 employees in Ontario on the date of posting are exempt. The guidelines state that records of the posting and related applications must be kept for three years after being removed from public access. This includes related documents linked to the posting, and if the posting has been modified, each version that was made public must be retained.

However, this retention obligation does not mean that every version must be made public to the applicant. What I would like to see added is a feature that allows applicants to view the previous salary range and the timing of the change whenever it is updated. Being able to compare the conditions seen at the time of application with subsequent changes would make the disclosed figures more helpful for decision-making.

Recruitment conditions can change based on experience or the responsibilities involved. The Ontario guidelines also specify that there is no obligation to make an actual offer exactly according to the amount or range listed in the posting. Therefore, I do not intend for this suggestion of keeping a history of changes to imply that salaries should be unchangeable. This is my opinion based on overseas record-keeping rules and does not explain current obligations in South Korea.

Three years is the duration for which an employer must keep a copy of a posting. That figure alone does not guarantee the applicant the right to receive the salary listed in the posting.

Discoversulately

It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…

급여 범위의 하한은 지키는 약속이어야 해요 — View post
ContributionSelected: Mandatory salary range disclosure

분리생각@recycle_thoughts

Translated from Korean

The lower bound of a salary range should be a binding promise

Let's say a hypothetical job posting states a "salary of 30–50 million KRW." If an employer offers 28 million KRW for the same job and working conditions after an interview, the applicant might feel their time was wasted for trusting those initial figures. I support mandatory salary range disclosure, and I believe the lower bound, at the very least, must be a binding promise.

The UK Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) published a consultation on November 10 that includes a framework addressing this issue. It proposes two options: either mandating a binding minimum salary, or disclosing both a binding lower bound and a reference upper bound. The CMA highlights the balance between providing information to job seekers while maintaining competition and salary negotiations. Note that this is a consultation document, not an indication that it has already been adopted into final UK law.

Disclosing a salary doesn't automatically mean the lower bound will be strictly honored. Guidance from British Columbia, Canada, requires employers to state the reasonable expected salary at the time of the posting, while also noting that applicants may request an amount outside that range or employers may offer one. We must interpret the requirement to show numbers alongside what exactly those numbers commit the employer to.

In the design I support, it should be clear that an employer cannot offer less than 30 million KRW to someone applying for the same role under the same working conditions. There is no need for the 50 million KRW to be a guaranteed amount for everyone or a ceiling for negotiations. If the upper bound is a reference figure that varies based on experience, that should be stated clearly. This preserves room for company negotiation while setting a solid baseline that applicants can expect.

Discoversulately

It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…

급여 범위를 공개할 때 판매수당 포함 여부도 밝혀야 해요 — View post
ContributionSelected: Mandatory salary range disclosure

말랑focus@softfocus_observer

Translated from Korean

When disclosing salary ranges, you should also specify whether sales commissions are included

Including sales commissions, which vary based on performance, in job postings might create more work for companies. Still, I support the mandatory disclosure of salary ranges. Even with the same salary range, the information provided to applicants differs depending on whether it refers only to the base salary or includes sales commissions.

The Canadian province of British Columbia requires employers to list expected salaries in public job postings, but advises that sales commissions can be listed at the employer's discretion. Ontario requires employers to list details for each type of compensation if the expected pay consists of multiple components. For example, if a position pays an hourly rate plus sales commissions, they suggest explaining both.

Some bonuses are difficult to predict, as both the timing and the amount can be uncertain. The Ontario guide also explains that companies are not required to make an actual job offer within the range stated in the posting. Therefore, it would be better to list the base salary range separately in the posting, specify whether sales commissions are included, and explain what conditions those commissions depend on.

Discoversulately

It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…

공고가 없어도 면접 전에는 급여 범위를 알려줘야 해요 — View post
ContributionSelected: Mandatory salary range disclosure

회의퀴클리@meetingover_zz

Translated from Korean

Even without a job posting, salary ranges should be disclosed before interviews

Imagine receiving an email with only an interview date. Without a job posting, you have to set aside time without even knowing the salary range. I support making salary range disclosure mandatory. Even when hiring without a formal posting, companies should be required to provide the salary range in writing before an interview so that candidates can make an informed decision before committing their time.

The UK government has announced plans to introduce legislation requiring salary information in job postings, or to be disclosed in writing to candidates before interviews if no posting exists. What we can confirm right now is the legislative policy announced by the government.

Final offers can vary based on experience or specific job responsibilities. Ontario also clarifies that the obligation to include expected compensation in job postings does not mean that employers are mandated to offer the exact salary or range initially disclosed.

Information provided before an interview is a key factor in deciding whether to proceed. If the final offer differs from the initial range, it would be helpful if the reasons for that change were also explained in writing.

Discoversulately

It's honestly frustrating when job postings just say 'salary negotiable'. It’s been announced that the UK is planning to make it mandatory by law to disclose salary ranges in job postings. It doesn't seem to be in effect…

You're all caught up.